Dear Lit Loves,
Greetings! Hope you had a safe Thanksgiving and were able to visit with family and friends. This month I was not inclined to re-read my book club's selection for the month of December so I did what any emerging yet unknown writer would do: I selected two books written in my favorite genre, memoir! Let me clarify and say I like memoirs by everyday people and NOT celebrity memoirs.
The second memoir I selected for the month of December is titled Two Truths and a Lie: A Murder, A Private Investigator, And Her Search For Justics by Ellen McGarrahan. I wanted to read this book because its author worked as an investigative reporter for many years in Miami, New York City, and San Francisco. She later found her calling as a private investigator. While working as an investigative reporter in Florida, she volunteers to witness and write about the execution of a man named Jesse Tafero. A Florida jury found him guilty of killing two police officers at a rest stop on February 20th, 1976. He was sentenced to death via electric chair. Ellen went to observe the execution and was traumatized by what she witnessed. She thought the whole process would be over and done with in at most several minutes. That is not what happened.
When Jesse Tafero was brought into the execution chamber and strapped into the electric chair, officers secured a headset atop his shaved head. When an anonymous person flipped the switch to electrocute Jesse Tafero, the headset bolted to his head catches fire. Jesse clenched his fists and slammed upward and back in the chair. Ellen could tell Jesse was still breathing. Then anonymous person flipped the switch a second time and Jesse's head is nodding, chest is still heaving, and he is still breathing. All total, it took seven minutes and three electrical jolts before Jesse Tafero was pronounced dead. Ellen remains haunted for years by what she witnessed that morning. And she wonders if the state executed the guilty party in this grisly crime. Eventually, she becomes a private investigator and returns to Florida to piece together the state's evidence involving the crime and speak with some of the parties involved in the crime. She also speaks with many of the people that were most effected by the crime and the people who were involved in investigating and bringing this case to trial.
Essentially, the book demonstrates how Ellen went about getting to the truth of who was really guilty in this particular crime. She wanted to know this truth so she could come to some sense of peace regarding if the proper criminals were truly held accountable and because she was so traumatized by the state's botched execution of an individual who was found guilty in the case. Which of the people involved in the crime were telling the truth and which people were lying? She goes through box after box of evidence even recreating the bodily figures of each person who was present on the morning of the crime. She speaks to family members, prosecuting attorneys, a polygrapher, and even two defendants who were sentenced for the crime. She needs to know the truth so she can release the obsession she has with the case.
Actually, this book was quite different from what I thought it would be. The book's inside cover said it would be a profound meditation on grief, complicity, and justice. And all those elements are there in the book. Ultimately, I think the book pushes the reader to consider how he/she feels about the death penalty and how the death penalty is enacted. For me, the book proved that when an individual tells and shows you who they are, believe them. I think that last sentence that I wrote was from the writing of the brilliant Maya Angelou. The book also left me pondering some questions like will our country ever implement gun control laws? Why are young kids and teenagers in this country able to obtain guns so easily? Are parents ever able to look at their child's behavior and actions objectively? Why are guns and violence so prevalent in our society? Do parents ever realize that the life they choose to lead and the people with whom they associate can greatly scar or benefit the type of person a child grows up to be? When citizens of this country are asked to serve on a death penalty case, are they seeing all the evidence and testimony that they should be allowed to view and consider before making a decision on whether a defendant is guilty or innocent and whether that person should be sentenced to life in prison without parole or be given the death penalty?
Finally, I think it goes without saying that this book will make you think about some often uncomfortable topics. It will make you ask yourself where you stand on the subjects of guns and violence. It will show you the grief caused by drugs, guns, and inconceivable crimes that surround us all each day. In conclusion, I would recommend this book. I wanted to reach out to the author on Goodreads, but I was not given the option of connecting with her though the Goodreads website. I had some questions for her that I would have liked to ask her about the book. I would also like to know if she ever truly found peace after what she witnessed and what she discovered after all her research, travels, and interviews.
Till my next review, observation, or meditation,
Best,
Grace (Amy)
No comments:
Post a Comment