Review: The Guardians by John Grisham

 Dear Literary Loves,

Greetings!  And once again I have returned to one of my favorite authors, John Grisham.  He writes the best crime fiction and he is someone who as an established and successful writer, connected with me as I was struggling to write and obtain publication in the memoir genre.  In this particular book titled, The Guardians, Grisham gives readers an inside fictional look into the life of an attorney who represents those who have been wrongly convicted. The book has much to offer regarding how and why wrongful convictions happen as well as the arbitrary nature of the U.S. judicial system.

Initially, the main focus of the book is on a case where an attorney in the small town of Seabrook, Florida, is shot and killed while working in his law office late one evening.  The killer left no clues, there are no witnesses to the crime, and there appears to be no one with a motive to kill the attorney.  The local sheriff handles the investigation of the murder.  He turns his attention to a black man and former client of the dead attorney known as Quincy Miller.    People say Quincy Miller was not happy with Keith Russo, the deceased attorney, and how Russo boggled Miller's representation during a recent divorce.  There are folks who say Quincy Miller openly expressed his disappointment in Russo's handling of his divorce.  Some even say Miller made threatening phone calls to Attorney Keith Russo.  Before too long, the sheriff has a witness who says she saw a man similar to Quincy Miller running from the lawyer's office the night of the shooting.  Next, a flashlight with what looks to be blood specks on the lens of the flashlight is found in the trunk of Quincy Miller's car.  It is taken as evidence by the sheriff who puts the flashlight evidence into a box, stores it in a shed, and before a trial can take place, this evidence is supposedly destroyed by a fire ignited in the evidence storage shed.

Quincy Miller finds himself being prosecuted for the murder of Keith Russo.  A murder weapon was never found.  Miller's ex-wife testifies that he did own a shotgun and several pistols.  A jailhouse snitch testifies that while he was locked up in a cell with Miller, he heard Quincy Miller brag about killing Attorney Keith Russo.  Quincy Miller is tried, convicted, and sentenced to life in prison.  He continues to advocate his innocence, but he has no attorney and no legal advocate.  He has a brother who visits him monthly in prison and sends Quincy money via check when he has extra income.  

Quincy Miller desperately writes to Guardian Ministries, a group that specializes in taking on cases where innocent men and women were convicted and sentenced to prison.  Cullen Post is the attorney at Guardian Ministries along with his partner, Vicki and assistant, Mazy who vote to take on Quincy Miller's case after reviewing the trial transcript and files along with the lack of a murder weapon and missing case evidence.  This crew has won 8 cases in which prisoners were shown to be wrongfully convicted and are serving time for a crime that someone else committed.  The question then becomes:  Will they have enough time to find missing evidence, interview trial witnesses, and proceed with DNA testing to determine if Quincy Miller and a few other prisoners are actually serving time for a crime they never committed?

I liked this book because there are few attorneys who are willing and have the time to devote to reviewing a convicted prisoner's case file to determine if the individual might have been wrongfully convicted.  In this book, the attorney who reviews Quincy's criminal case works mostly pro bono, spends a lot of time on the road tracking down witnesses and having evidence tested for DNA components.  Guardian Ministries depends on donations to keep the doors open.  Cullen Post, the innocence attorney in Quincy Miller's case actually lives in a room above the offices of Guardian Ministries.  Just the amount of time he spends traveling from one state to another is overwhelming.  And he carries affidavits with him on a near constant basis should he find a trial witness who is willing to say they lied in a criminal case.  It's a job that takes dedication and endless reserves of energy and a phenomenal curiosity.

This book also allows the reader to see the dysfunction in our criminal justice system.  A jury for a criminal trial does not always get the right person convicted.  And this happens because sometimes the people behind the crimes are paying off witnesses, witnesses may lie while testifying in court simply to retaliate against the person being prosecuted, law enforcement may utilize a convicted prisoner to obtain information from a defendant while in jail, and trial evidence may have been planted or destroyed intentionally to cover up and protect who really committed the crime.  

According to what I read in this book, there are more than two million people locked up in prison in the United States and it takes one million employees and over eighty million dollars to house and care for the prison population.  The book made me wonder how many prisoners in the United States are actually truly innocent and may pay the ultimate price  of death for a crime they did not commit and how many prisoners have lost their freedoms and rights as citizens for a crime that someone else actually committed?  This book will make you think about our often chaotic judicial system and also give you an added degree of skepticism if you are ever called to be a jury member on a criminal case.  Another well-written book by John Grisham.  I never expect anything less from one of my favorite authors.  I highly recommend the book, The Guardians by John Grisham.

Till my next review,

Grace (Amy)